
By Tim McAlpine
I added a new blog category: Wet Blanket. Talking to the The CU Skeptic has rubbed off on me a little.

Many credit unions hang their reputation and their brand on a claim of superior member service. Not only is this not a significant marketplace differentiator, in my experience, it is not necessarily true.
I have 100% of my personal and business banking with one of Canada's 10 largest credit unions. On the personal side, I have been with this credit union for over a decade. On the professional side, I moved my business account within the last two years from one of the big five Canadian banks to my credit union. I felt strongly that if Currency was going to work only with credit unions that we should do our business banking with a credit union.
Eryn Fraser, our Director of Finance, works two-and-half-days a week. This means that at least once every two weeks, I visit the credit union to do the banking. I have been into the branch more than 50 times in the last two years, yet the front-line staff still don't know my name. Even though they have a seven-figure CRM system, they don't even try to fake-know me.
After I have made a deposit or paid some bills, the conversation typically goes like this:
Tim says, "May I have my balance please?"
Jennifer or Terry says, "Are you a signer?"
Every 20 visits or so, throw me a bone with something like:
"Hey Tim, how's that credit union marketing thing going?"
Would that be so hard?
As I have made it abundantly clear on this blog, I have a personal connection with the credit union movement. Fundamentally, I don't like what huge banks stand for with their focus on driving shareholder profit above all else. However, the personal service that I received from my previous bank was actually superior to the service that I now receive from my credit union. A number of the bank tellers knew me by name and regularly asked me how my business was going and how my wife and kids where doing.
I have written a number of CU Branding 101 posts that describe in detail why your credit union needs to differentiate on more than service, but since so few credit unions are taking my advice, let's talk about this built-in credit union promise of superior service.
If your credit union is going to continue to proclaim that your people are your difference, your credit union needs to prove it. Everyday.
As your credit union grows, great service must be part of your organization's DNA. Great service must be a mandatory job requirement from every staff member. These simple steps would make a big difference to your members:
Is my experience isolated? Is your credit union's service really superior?

P.S. I know Jennifer and Terry because they wear name tags. Maybe I should get one!
01/09/2008
By Tim McAlpine
I read this article written by By Eileen Courter with interest. Mark Weber from Weber Marketing provides most of the content and he offers some terrific, straight-forward advice that credit union marketers should pay attention to.
|
Mark Weber says, "If good service were the secret, credit unions would be thriving in membership growth today," he continues. "Unfortunately, good service is not the bar by which people switch financial institutions. We've had seven years of the worst growth in history in credit union membership. You absolutely have to be working much, much harder than simply saying 'We have great member service' when everyone else is saying it." Weber notes that even though some 20% of credit unions now have a community charter, the vast majority are not growing. "There are two big surprises when a credit union gains a community charter," Weber says. "First, absolutely nobody is beating a path to your door. No. 2, you have to completely transform your business, operational, and sales models." |
+ Take a read—more food for thought.
It all points back to the real need for your credit union to be different and desirable.

01/03/2008
By Tim McAlpine
A recent post on Robbie Wright's Life and Times of a CU Employee blog raised a completely separate issue for me. And it irks me whenever I see it.
Read all of the messaging on this website home page and see if you can see my pet peeve.

There is a huge disconnect between the built-in brand position set in the credit union name (Queensland Teachers' Credit Union Limited) and the tagline that attempts to reverse that built-in positioning (for teachers and anyone who has ever had one). How can you appeal to absolutely everyone with a name that is meant to appeal to a chosen few?
The very clear name states that this is a credit union specifically formed to serve teachers who live in Queensland. This is a crystal clear position that differentiates this credit union from all of its competitors.
I speculate that somewhere in the credit union's history the leadership and board determined that the credit union needed to grow in order to survive.
Two ways to grow:
Before you even consider option 2, you need to exhaust the potential of option 1. Work to have your credit union resonate with the majority of your field of membership and entice your non-members within that field to become members and participate by offering unique products and services that are actually built for their unique needs. After studying the website, I do applaud Queensland Teachers' for having a dedicated tab and a number of great products just for teachers.
If you do go for option 2, you have to go all the way. You need to change your name and build a compelling brand position. Slapping on a new, completely open-ended tagline will not get the results you envisioned when you opened your bond. A brand position must be clear and avoid confusion.
Also, don't even get me started on the acronym solution. It may be easy to go with QTCU, but acronyms are cold, emotionless and easily forgotten.
The golden carrot of an unlimited position never performs like imagined. The problem with trying to appeal to everyone is you actually appeal to no one. And if you do attempt to appeal to everyone, at least avoid confusion in your name and tagline. It's never a great strategy to weaken your unique brand position to the point of confusion.

P.S. If you found this unusually harsh for my blog posts, I apologize. This is a huge pet peeve of mine.
It is not my practice to dump on credit union marketing and branding. I think we are all in this together and there are enough blogs that throw out negative energy just to generate traffic and comments. I am using Queensland Teachers' Credit Union Limited as an example to help illustrate a point that applies to credit unions in transition from closed bond (limited fields of membership) to open bond (community charter fields).
12/27/2007
By Tim McAlpine
In our CU Branding 101 series, I have expressed my opinion that credit unions are undifferentiated. To add to the confusion, there are actually three levels of undifferentiated consumer-facing credit union brands you as a credit union marketer have to deal with!
Let's look at the impact that each level has on your credit union.
After more than a century there is still a lot of misunderstanding about what a credit union is, what makes a credit union different and why that difference matters.
When we ask the general public to describe what a credit union is, we get responses that range from a shrug to credit unions are like banks, only smaller. A small percentage of folks will indicate one or two of the following: cooperative, member owned, involved in the community, great service, local decision making, friendly people, not-for-profit, too small, employer sponsored, exclusive and less sophisticated than banks.
To those that do understand what a credit union is, the credit union movement brand does have an impact on your credit union brand. The credit union movement brand creates a pre-disposition to be open to or closed to what your credit union has to offer. That is it. Nothing more, nothing less.
If most people don't understand what makes a credit union different from a bank, even less people understand what makes your credit union different from another credit union down the street.
In a competitive environment, your credit union not only needs to be perceived as different than the banks, it also has to be different from other credit unions in your marketplace. The little known category differentiators go out the window when folks are asked to identify what the difference is between competing credit unions.
And finally, if people don't understand what makes a credit union different from a bank and what makes your credit union different from the credit union down the street, then they really don't understand what makes your credit union's products and services different from everyone else's.
That's because credit union product and services aren't significantly different. This is why the financial services industry has been reduced to a commodity where most decisions are based solely on price.
When we ask credit union marketers to list brands that matter, Apple is always included in the list. Think about this. Apple does not promote the category or the organization, Apple promotes its offers: the Mac, iPod, iPhone, Apple TV, iTunes, iLife, Mac OSX and Final Cut Pro to name a few. Through product innovation and consumers' experience with Apple's products (the offer), the Apple brand is built and propelled forward. The offer is where the money is made and the brand is built.
Below is a video that is part of a new Burger King promotion, "The Whopper Freakout."
Watch this video and then ask yourself, does your credit union have an offer on its menu that members are so passionate about that, if removed, would cause a massive freakout? Does your credit union have the equivalent of a Burger King Whopper?
Boy, that was a long post to prove a simple point. Offer great products and services and the rest will take care of itself.

10/29/2007
By Tim McAlpine
This is a new category: scary big ideas. I was going to call it "wild ideas that credit unions will never go for, but should, because these ideas, if executed with courage and commitment, would really fly" but it was too long and wouldn't fit in the category menu.
Think of this new category as a fringe third-year course taught by an eccentric that doesn't have very many students.
Some background on this scary big idea
There is a general consensus that credit unions need to be bigger and need to have an unlimited field of membership to compete. So the once tightly defined fields of membership have given way to the new looser, we-are-open-to-everyone fields of membership.
For many credit unions that have made this jump, there is a sense of surprise and wonder that this new openness has not yielded hoards of new members flocking in to open new accounts and move their mortgages.
So, the next conclusion drawn is to offer better rates, free chequing accounts and free George Foreman grills to compete in these highly competitive multi-credit union markets.
What if there was another answer?
What if the decision to become more open was flawed? What if when an original field of membership is deemed to be irrelevant and unsustainable, we redefined an equally tight, but more relevant field of membership?
What if we defined our fields of membership by affinity?
Here are some dictionary definitions for affinity:
When I think of large groups of employees or even neighbours, there is very little shared affinity. The relationships we have with our coworkers and neighbours are not based on shared passion, they are based on mere acquaintance: "Hey Bob, how was your weekend?" "Fine, Dave, how was your weekend?" "Fine."
Huh? What the heck am I talking about?
Put all of the "it will never happen" thoughts that are racing through you mind aside and think like the CEO of a start-up for a second. If you opened a new credit union today with no members, how would you go about building your business from nothing? This new credit union would have be highly differentiated with a story so compelling that a select group of very passionate early adopters would promote it for you. Your new credit union would need to build around shared affinity.
Here are some ideas for narrow affinity based fields of membership
I could go on and on. My point is that affinity has incredible power, more so than shared geography, shared demographics or a shared employer and affinity has nothing to do with the highest or lowest rates. You products and services would simply have to be competitive, not earth shattering.
Before you cast this crazy idea aside, consider the affinity and passion that Harley Davidson owners share. Or the affinity and passion that Apple computer owners share. Affinity could be the next killer app for credit unions.
Or, you can tell the eccentric teacher to put a sock in it! What do you think?

10/13/2007
By Tim McAlpine
In 1998, Al Ries and Laura Ries penned The 22 Immutable Laws of Branding. It is a great follow up to Al Ries and Jack Trout's 1981 book Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind.
The concepts and ideas presented in these two books form the underlying principles practiced by today's leading brand experts.
Some will argue that there are exceptions to these rules and believe that nothing is immutable, meaning 'not subject to or susceptible to change.' However, for the purposes of this blog post, let's believe them at face value and measure the typical credit union brand against 12 of these widely accepted laws. I eliminated 10 of the laws for this discussion to keep this relatively short
I'll use a scale between 1 to 5 for a possible total of 60 points.
By my non-scientific count, the average credit union scores 25 out of 60 (42%). This is an F. I think we have some work to do! If you actually read this far, aren't you glad I only included 12 of the laws?

09/22/2007
By Tim McAlpine
This is my second CU Branding 101 post. If you didn't read the first, here's a link. Don't worry, this post will wait until you get back!
OK, so you get the gist. My fundamental belief is that credit unions need to be differentiated to succeed long term, yet almost all credit unions are not significantly differentiated. To illustrated my point, let me contrast the financial services industry with the television industry.
Fifty years ago, there were only three channels to choose from.

Occupying a unique position in consumers' minds was easy. As long as you filled the schedule with a variety of programs, you were guaranteed to have an audience and a full roster of advertisers.
Fast-forward to today and there are dozens of stations to choose from. By necessity, new stations are differentiated to attract an audience and advertisers. The difference between every station is obvious.
Most stations have a descriptive name and a defined niche they are seeking to connect with. Just think of The History Channel, Much Music, The Golf Channel, SportsNet, The Shopping Channel and Court TV to name a few.

To contrast, this is how the financial services industry looks from the consumers' point of view. There are dozens of brands that essentially look like the big banks that established the marketplace. Each going after the same target with essentially the same story and offering. The differences are so subtle and are not compelling. 
If you don't believe me, ask your spouse, kids or neighbours to describe the difference between 10 financial institutions.
Think about how well positioned TV stations are in comparison. TV stations have the added bonus of being able to promote their offerings on other channels, in TV Guide and in the local daily newspaper. Also, let's not forget that consumers can access every choice from the couch!
Here's the irony. As competition has intensified, credit unions have moved away from the things that naturally made them different.
These shifts have been done to appeal to larger groups of people. However, as more credit unions compete against one another and more alternative players enter the scene, all institutions are looking and feeling the same.
To make matters worse, consumer can't easily sample financial products and services.
Owning a differentiated position has become crucial. Your position has to be so differentiated and compelling to even get noticed. And by the way, being community oriented, member owned and providing better service is not a differentiated position.
These principles may seem obvious, yet most credit union leaders are afraid to position their organizations for fear of limiting their credit union's potential.

09/09/2007
By Tim McAlpine
Since we call our blog the CU Brand Blog, I feel I should do a few posts on Currency's credit union brand beliefs and branding process. I'll title and tag these posts 'CU Branding 101.'
Before I get into some real meat in future posts, let me communicate 10 of our basic beliefs about branding for credit unions:
This post sets the stage for upcoming CU Branding 101 posts. My intent is to unseat some long-held beliefs on credit union branding and push credit unions to step up and identify and claim their difference.

Viewing 1 - 8 of 8 |
August 20, 2010
Lack of young blood runs deeper than membership
(1 Comment)
August 8, 2010
Young, Free and Super-charged
July 28, 2010
There actually IS meat on bacon!
July 19, 2010
Co-op Vegas?
(2 Comments)

Why Gen Y Live
Thursdays at 1 PM PST
+ Watch live
28 | Sarah Dale Simpkins
27 | Alex Oliver
26 | Mark Arnold
25 | Denise Wymore
24 | Eric Acree
23 | Matt Vance
22 | Josh Garrett
21 | Peter Glyman
20 | Jonathan Gowins
19 | Charlie Elliot
18 | Chris Anderson
17 | Ben Rogers
16 | Erin Templer
15 | Josh Reams
14 | Carla Day
13 | Our Contest Winners
12 | Gen Y Showcase
11 | Video Contest Results
10 | Carol Phillips
09 | Josh Sutherland
08 | Jessica Wade
07 | Brady Will
06 | Morriss Partee
05 | Ron Shevlin
04 | Myles Peterman
03 | Matt Davis
02 | Andy LaFlamme
01 | Brent Dixon
Credit Union Innovators
+ Subscribe in iTunes
19 | Larissa Walkiw
18 | Eric Dillon
17 | Christopher Morris
16 | Jeffry Pilcher
15 | Jump the Shark
14 | Trey Reeme
13 | James Anderson
12 | Bryan Sims
11 | Shari Storm
10 | Denise Wymore
09 | Morriss Partee
08 | Matt Davis
07 | Tom Webb
06 | Ginny Brady
05 | Doug True
04 | CU Skeptic
03 | William Azaroff
02 | Wayne McKay
01 | Gene Blishen
CUES Experience Podcast
+ Subscribe in iTunes
04 | Ron Shevlin
03 | Arkadi Kuhlman
02 | Conference highlights
01 | Steve Williams
Community Credit Union & Growth Conference
Boston, Massachusetts
10-08-2010
+ Visit site
HOW MYOB Conference
10-13-2010
New York, NY
+ Visit site
CU Water Cooler Symposium
10-28-2010
Fishers, Indiana
+ Visit site
Interested in having Tim McAlpine speak at your next credit union event?
+ Tim's profile (PDF)
+ Visit speaking page
+ Book Tim now!